Welcome to The Berean Project Podcast!

What Does Biblical Submission Actually Mean?

Few words in Christian vocabulary carry more assumptions than submission. Depending on someone's church background, the word may immediately bring to mind authority, obedience, hierarchy, marriage, leadership, or the idea of placing yourself under someone else's direction.  Sometimes the concept is presented very simply: God establishes authority, certain people are placed under that authority, and faithfulness means submitting to the people God has placed over you.  But is that what the New Testament means by submission?  Before deciding who is supposed to submit to whom, perhaps we should ask a more basic question: What kind of relationship is the New Testament trying to create when it talks about submission?

Start With the Word

One of the primary Greek words translated submit in the New Testament is hypotassō. It can carry the idea of arranging under, being subject to, or yielding. In some contexts, hierarchy clearly exists. The New Testament uses the word in several different kinds of relationships, so context determines how the idea functions.  That matters because an English word can accumulate meanings that are not necessarily present every time the original word appears. When modern Christians hear “submit,” we may immediately imagine a chain of command. Someone has authority. Someone else follows instructions.

Sometimes that may be part of the context.  But it should not automatically become our definition before we read the passage.  Submission can also describe a voluntary posture of yielding, consideration, cooperation, and putting another person's interests ahead of our own. The surrounding context has to tell us what kind of submission is being described.

Start With One Another

One of the most important passages in this discussion appears in Ephesians 5. Conversations about submission often begin with verse 22: “Wives, submit yourselves to your own husbands.”  But Paul's thought begins earlier.  Ephesians 5:21 says, Submit to one another out of reverence for Christ.”  Whatever follows has to be read with that sentence in view. Paul is describing a Christian community shaped by something radically different from self-promotion. People filled with the Spirit sing together, give thanks together, and submit to one another.

That creates an interesting starting point.  Submission is not introduced simply as something lower-ranking Christians give higher-ranking Christians. It appears as a posture Christians practice toward one another.  Before submission becomes a discussion about authority, it is already a discussion about relationship.

Jesus Turned the Hierarchy Upside Down

The disciples repeatedly struggled with status. They wanted to know who was greatest. James and John wanted positions of prominence. They understood leadership through the categories available in their world: someone rises, someone else serves.  Jesus repeatedly disrupted that thinking.

In Mark 10, he points to Gentile rulers who “lord it over” others and exercise authority over them. Then he tells his disciples, “Not so with you.” Whoever wants to become great must become a servant, and whoever wants to be first must become slave of all.  Jesus does not simply tell the people at the bottom to submit more effectively.  He tells the people who want to be at the top to stop thinking that way.  That is important when discussing biblical submission because Jesus' model of Christian community cannot be separated from Jesus' understanding of power.

Submission Is Not the Same as Obedience

We often use submit and obey as though they mean exactly the same thing. But the New Testament does not always treat them that way.  Submission can involve yielding to another person without surrendering moral responsibility. We do this regularly. We defer to expertise. We cooperate with decisions. We place another person's needs ahead of our preferences. We choose not to insist on getting our own way.  None of those actions requires us to stop thinking.

Biblical submission therefore should not automatically mean, Another person makes the decision and my responsibility is to comply.”  That becomes especially important when another person's instruction conflicts with conscience or faithfulness to God. Acts 5 records Peter and the apostles telling authorities, “We must obey God rather than human beings.” Whatever submission to human authority means, it clearly has limits.  No human relationship removes a person's responsibility before God.

Submission Can Be Powerful Because It Is Voluntary

There is something else worth noticing about submission: forced submission is almost a contradiction.  If someone says, “Submit to me or I will punish, shame, exclude, or discredit you,” what is being produced may be compliance rather than submission.  Biblical submission seems far more meaningful when it is voluntarily given. I choose to listen. I choose to yield. I choose to consider your needs. I choose not to insist that everything happen according to my preferences.

That kind of submission requires strength rather than passivity.  Jesus washing the disciples' feet in John 13 provides a striking picture. He knows who he is. He is not uncertain about his identity or position. Yet he takes the posture of a servant and washes feet.  He does not lose authority by serving.  He demonstrates what authority looks like in the kingdom of God.

Submission Does Not Eliminate Boundaries

This distinction matters because biblical language about submission has sometimes been used in unhealthy situations.  A person may be told to remain silent about mistreatment because submission requires it. A church member may be told not to question leadership. A spouse may be pressured to tolerate destructive behavior. Someone raising legitimate concerns may be accused of having a rebellious spirit.

But submission does not require pretending that harm is good.  Jesus confronted people. Paul challenged Peter. The prophets confronted kings. Early Christians sometimes refused the commands of authorities. The New Testament contains no vision of faithfulness that requires turning off moral judgment.  A person can have a submissive posture and still say no.  They can listen respectfully and disagree.  They can value another person while establishing a boundary.  They can pursue peace without surrendering conscience.

Maybe Submission Begins With “You First”

Our natural instinct is to ask, “Who is supposed to submit to me?”  The New Testament repeatedly redirects the question.  Paul tells believers to honor one another above themselves. He tells them to look not only to their own interests but also to the interests of others. Jesus tells his disciples to serve. Peter tells elders not to lord authority over people but to become examples to the flock.  The pattern keeps moving in the same direction.

Christian maturity is not primarily demonstrated by successfully getting other people underneath us. It is demonstrated by becoming increasingly willing to use our freedom, strength, knowledge, and influence for their good.  Perhaps submission makes the most sense when we stop using it as a word that describes what someone else owes us and begin using it to describe the posture we voluntarily bring into relationships.

What Does Submission Look Like in a Church?

In a healthy Christian community, submission may look much less dramatic than we imagine.  It can mean listening when someone challenges us. Allowing another person's needs to inconvenience us. Receiving correction without immediately becoming defensive. Giving experienced leaders room to lead. Refusing to insist that our preference must become everyone's preference. Being willing to change our mind when someone shows us something we have missed and because submission is relational, leaders participate too.

A pastor can submit to the wisdom of the congregation. An elder can listen to someone with less experience. A teacher can reconsider an interpretation. A leader can surrender a preferred plan because another person's idea is better.  “Submit to one another” becomes difficult to practice if submission only travels in one direction.

Submission Is Not the Surrender of Conscience

Perhaps this is the distinction that matters most.  Biblical submission calls us away from self-centeredness. It challenges our need to win, control, dominate, and always get our own way. It invites us to listen, yield, serve, and consider others.  But none of that requires giving another human being ownership of our conscience.  We remain responsible for what we believe. We remain responsible for what we do. We remain responsible for testing what we are taught and seeking what is true.

Submission can shape how we disagree without determining whether we are allowed to disagree.  Maybe that is why the New Testament vision is more challenging than simple obedience. Following orders can sometimes be easy. Mutual submission requires humility from everyone—including the person with the title.  And that leaves us with another question worth wrestling with:  What is spiritual authority?