Welcome to The Berean Project Podcast!

What Does Repentance Have to Do with Identity?

Repentance is often presented as a religious obligation: recognize your sin, feel remorse, ask for forgiveness, and change your behavior. While these elements may be involved, the biblical understanding of repentance reaches deeper than correcting individual actions. It challenges how we understand ourselves, what shapes our decisions, and who we are becoming.

But does repentance mean rejecting who we are? Does following Jesus require abandoning our identity and replacing it with a religiously approved version? Or might repentance involve discovering an identity that has been obscured by habits, assumptions, fears, and expectations?

These questions matter because the way we understand repentance can profoundly influence the way we understand God, ourselves, and the possibility of genuine transformation.

What Did Repentance Mean in Its Original Context?

The Greek word commonly translated as repentance is metanoia, related to the verb metanoeĊ. It conveys a change of mind or understanding, often involving a reorientation of one's life. In biblical contexts, repentance is not merely changing an opinion. It involves reconsidering the direction of one's life in response to a new understanding of God and his purposes.

The Hebrew Scriptures frequently describe repentance through the language of returning. The Hebrew verb shuv means to turn or return, and it is often used when Israel is called to return to God after pursuing other loyalties. In passages such as Hosea 14:1–2, repentance is framed as returning to a relationship rather than simply correcting a list of offenses.

These concepts provide an important foundation. Repentance involves more than regret over what has happened. It invites people to reconsider where they are going, what they trust, and what has been directing their lives.

Why Did Jesus Connect Repentance With the Kingdom of God?

When Jesus began his public ministry, his announcement was striking: "Repent, for the kingdom of heaven has come near" (Matthew 4:17). The call to repentance was connected directly to the arrival of God's kingdom. Jesus was not simply announcing that people needed to improve their behavior. He was declaring that God's reign was breaking into their world and inviting them to respond.  For his original audience, this announcement challenged deeply established expectations. Many Jewish people anticipated God's intervention in ways that would restore Israel and confront its enemies. Jesus, however, described a kingdom characterized by unexpected reversals: the humble are lifted up, enemies are loved, and greatness is expressed through service.

Consider the Sermon on the Mount in Matthew 5–7. Jesus repeatedly challenged familiar assumptions about righteousness, status, retaliation, wealth, and relationships. His teaching invited listeners to reconsider not only what they did but also the values and loyalties that shaped their understanding of themselves.  In this context, repentance meant becoming willing to see the world differently because God's kingdom was revealing a different way to live.

How Does Our Identity Influence Our Behavior?

Much of human behavior grows out of the stories people tell themselves about who they are. Someone who sees themselves primarily as a successful professional may measure personal worth through achievement. Someone who has experienced repeated rejection may come to believe that being unwanted is a permanent part of their identity. Others may define themselves through family expectations, religious affiliations, personal failures, or the approval of their community.

These identities are not necessarily false or harmful. Our experiences, relationships, and responsibilities contribute to our understanding of ourselves. Problems arise, however, when a particular identity becomes so controlling that it prevents us from examining our assumptions or imagining another way of living.  The biblical call to repentance creates space for that examination. It raises questions about whether the beliefs directing our lives are trustworthy and whether the identities we have constructed reflect the kind of people God is inviting us to become.  This is why repentance can be uncomfortable. Changing a behavior may be difficult, but reconsidering the identity that supports that behavior can feel like losing a part of ourselves.

What Can We Learn From Peter's Changing Identity?

Peter provides a particularly useful example because the Gospels portray him as both deeply committed to Jesus and repeatedly mistaken about what that commitment required.  In Matthew 16:13–23, Peter identifies Jesus as the Messiah. Yet shortly afterward, when Jesus explains that suffering and death await him, Peter objects. Jesus responds with a sharp rebuke, telling Peter that he is setting his mind on human concerns rather than God's concerns.

Peter had correctly identified Jesus, but he had not fully understood what being the Messiah meant. His expectations about Jesus shaped his understanding of discipleship and, by extension, his own role as a follower.  Later, Peter confidently declares that he will remain loyal even if others abandon Jesus (Matthew 26:33–35). His subsequent denial exposes the gap between his self-understanding and his actual capacity under pressure. The man who believed himself unshakably faithful discovers that his confidence was misplaced.

Yet Peter's story does not end with failure. In John 21:15–19, the risen Jesus engages Peter in a conversation about love, responsibility, and following him. The narrative does not explicitly call this exchange repentance, but it illustrates the kind of reorientation repentance can involve. Peter's failure is neither ignored nor allowed to become the final definition of who he is.  His identity as a disciple continues to develop through correction, humility, and renewed responsibility.

Does Repentance Mean Becoming Someone Else?

Paul's letters introduce language that makes this question especially interesting. In 2 Corinthians 5:17, he describes those who are in Christ in terms of new creation. In Ephesians 4:22–24, believers are instructed to put off the old self and put on the new self, created according to God in righteousness and holiness.  These passages are sometimes interpreted as though becoming a Christian requires erasing one's personality, history, or individuality. But their surrounding contexts suggest a more specific concern.

In Ephesians 4, Paul contrasts patterns of thinking and behavior associated with the believers' former way of life against the practices appropriate to their new communal identity. He addresses dishonesty, anger, stealing, destructive speech, bitterness, kindness, and forgiveness. The emphasis is not on eliminating individuality but on transforming the patterns through which people relate to one another.  Likewise, Paul's language of new creation in 2 Corinthians appears within a discussion of reconciliation and a transformed way of regarding others. The change is not merely internal or private. It affects how people understand their relationship with God and with one another.  Repentance, then, need not mean becoming an entirely different personality. It may mean allowing previously unquestioned loyalties, assumptions, and behaviors to be reshaped by a different understanding of what it means to belong to Christ.

Can Religious Identity Become an Obstacle to Repentance?

One of the more challenging aspects of Jesus' ministry is that some of his strongest criticisms were directed toward people whose identities were closely connected to religious faithfulness.  In Luke 18:9–14, Jesus tells a parable about a Pharisee and a tax collector who go to the temple to pray. Luke introduces the parable by explaining that Jesus addressed people who trusted in their own righteousness and treated others with contempt.

The Pharisee's prayer emphasizes his religious practices and distinguishes him from those he considers morally inferior. The tax collector, by contrast, acknowledges his need for mercy. Jesus concludes that the tax collector, rather than the Pharisee, went home justified.

The point is not that religious discipline is inherently wrong or that all Pharisees were hypocritical. Rather, the parable challenges the assumption that religious achievement establishes a person's superiority before God.  This raises a difficult possibility: a religious identity can become so closely tied to being correct, faithful, or morally superior that repentance begins to feel threatening.  When someone believes their identity depends upon possessing the right answers, admitting error may seem like a betrayal of faith rather than an expression of it.  Could a willingness to reconsider our understanding actually be one of the clearest expressions of repentance?

What Is the Difference Between Repentance and Shame?

Repentance and shame can produce very different responses to personal failure.  Shame often moves from recognizing something wrong to making a judgment about the entire person. Instead of saying, "I did something harmful," someone may conclude, "I am fundamentally defective." When this judgment becomes central to personal identity, change can begin to feel impossible.  Biblical repentance, by contrast, calls people to acknowledge wrongdoing without necessarily defining them permanently by it.

Paul makes a related distinction in 2 Corinthians 7:8–11, where he contrasts godly grief that leads to repentance with worldly grief that produces death. His concern arises from a difficult relationship between himself and the Corinthian believers. Their sorrow mattered because it produced a constructive response rather than remaining an end in itself.  The passage does not offer a modern psychological definition of shame, but it does distinguish between sorrow that leads toward restoration and sorrow that produces destruction.  This distinction is significant. If repentance is intended to move people toward a renewed relationship with God and others, then permanently defining someone by their worst failure may undermine the very transformation repentance is meant to encourage.

Is Repentance a Single Decision or an Ongoing Process?

Repentance is sometimes presented as a decisive moment in which someone turns away from sin and toward God. Scripture certainly contains examples of significant turning points. Yet the broader biblical narrative also portrays transformation as something that continues over time.  Peter's development did not end with his restoration in John 21. In Galatians 2:11–14, Paul recounts confronting Peter in Antioch because Peter's behavior toward Gentile believers contradicted the implications of the gospel. Even after years of following Jesus, Peter still faced situations in which inherited assumptions and social pressures influenced his conduct.

This episode is especially revealing because it shows that theological understanding and lived behavior do not always develop at the same pace.  Paul's account does not explicitly describe Peter's response as repentance, nor does it tell us how Peter reacted afterward. Nevertheless, the confrontation illustrates why ongoing correction remains important within the Christian life.  Repentance may involve a decisive change of direction, but living consistently with that direction requires continued examination, humility, and growth.

What Happens When We Stop Defending Who We Think We Are?

Perhaps one of the greatest obstacles to repentance is the human desire to maintain a stable and favorable understanding of ourselves.  We develop explanations for our decisions, defend our convictions, and construct narratives that make our actions understandable. These processes are not always dishonest. They help us navigate a complicated world. But they can also make it difficult to recognize when our assumptions are mistaken or our behavior has become harmful.

Jesus' invitation to deny oneself and follow him (Mark 8:34–35) is often interpreted as a call to personal sacrifice. In its immediate context, however, it follows Peter's resistance to Jesus' announcement of suffering. The call challenges the instinct to preserve one's life and expectations on one's own terms rather than follow the path Jesus describes.  This does not require treating personal identity as worthless. It challenges the assumption that protecting our existing understanding of ourselves must always take priority.  Repentance becomes possible when we are willing to ask whether the person we are defending is the person we are actually called to become.

A Question Worth Wrestling With

What if repentance is not primarily about becoming a more religious version of ourselves, but about allowing our understanding of ourselves to be transformed?  The biblical language of turning, returning, and renewed thinking suggests that repentance involves a fundamental reconsideration of direction and loyalty. Jesus connected that invitation to the arrival of God's kingdom, while the New Testament letters describe its implications for relationships, community, and daily conduct.

This does not eliminate the importance of acknowledging wrongdoing or changing harmful behavior. It places those changes within a larger process of transformation.  Perhaps the most difficult part of repentance is not admitting that we have done something wrong. Perhaps it is becoming willing to question the assumptions, loyalties, and identities that made our actions seem right in the first place.  And if that is true, repentance may be less about defending the person we have always believed ourselves to be and more about remaining open to the person we are still becoming.

Questions for Further Reflection

  1. How much of your identity comes from convictions you have personally examined, and how much comes from expectations you inherited?

  2. Can a religious identity become an obstacle to recognizing where change is needed?

  3. What is the difference between acknowledging wrongdoing and allowing wrongdoing to define who you are?

  4. Does genuine repentance require changing our behavior, our understanding, or both?

  5. How might our relationships change if we viewed repentance as an ongoing process rather than a one-time religious event?

Historical Sources for Editorial Reference

  • The Hebrew Bible: Hosea 14:1–2; Ezekiel 18:30–32 — returning to God and turning from destructive conduct.

  • The Synoptic Gospels: Matthew 4:17; 16:13–23; 26:33–35; Luke 18:9–14; Mark 8:34–35 — repentance, discipleship, self-understanding, and religious confidence.

  • The Gospel of John: John 21:15–19 — Peter's restoration and renewed commission.

  • Pauline Letters: 2 Corinthians 5:16–21; 7:8–11; Ephesians 4:17–32; Galatians 2:11–14 — new creation, grief and repentance, transformed conduct, and ongoing correction.

  • BDAG: A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd edition — entries for metanoia and metanoeĊ.

  • Brown, Driver, Briggs: A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament — entry for shuv, particularly its use in returning to God.